I’ve often been told, “Don’t quit,” and, “no one wants a quitter,” and, “quitters will let you down.” At the time it sounded like good advice. Recently, though, I’ve begun to wonder. Why, with all of these “don’t quit” messages are we supportive of some kinds of quitters? Smokers, for instance, or recovering alcoholics. Is it really quitting that needs to be avoided, or is it something else?
I tell my students, “Never give up.” It follows the old adage, “It’s not over ‘til the fat lady sings.” There are many come-from-behind stories that seem to prove the idea that you’re not finished until the task is done. And yet, what about the stories of people ruining themselves because they followed the idea of “keep going until you succeed” blindly?
Somewhere between the two is the ideal. I’ve decided that, though the definitions are similar, quitting and giving up are not the same. Giving up implies a lack of will to keep going. Whether it’s from lack of emotional commitment, the idea that a task is physically impossible for you to do, or just that you believe that the situation is hopeless, giving up is about the situation dictating your actions.
Quitting is merely stopping an activity with no intention of returning to it. Quitting is about deciding for yourself what your actions will be. If you have the mental, emotional, and physical fortitude to keep going against seemingly impossible odds, if you retain the desire to keep trying, then when you stop, you are quitting, not giving up. In many cases, quitting requires that you be stronger at an emotional and mental level (even physical depending on the activity) than to keep going.
Making this mental switch to considering where the impetus for action comes from can be difficult. Especially if you are used to thinking quitting and giving up are the exact same thing. On one level, they do mean the same thing. They both mean stopping an activity. On the connotative level, though, they are nearly opposites. If you quit, you decide to stop. If you give up, the situation decides you will stop. The critical thought patterns are completely different. The person who gives up says, “I can’t.” The person who quits says, “If I don’t like where this is going, I won’t.”
So all you alcoholics and smoke-a-holics and whatever-holics, be quitters…and don’t give up quitting.